College Football Comes Down To This- Randy Routier
Monday, November 30th, 2009It has been a great year for college football and the end is near for this season. Despite surprises and ups and downs this season looks to be headed for a pretty simple ending. Here is how it looks to be shaking out as I see it. The BCS final will have Florida as the number one team taking on the number two team, the Texas Longhorns. Yes, both teams have not looked as strong as some expected but they both have continued to win. Do you want to pick against Tim Tebow or would you prefer to pick against Colt McCoy? I am leaning towards Texas to win it at this point. Of course I would prefer to see a playoff and wouldn’t it be great to see a tournament with TCU, Cincinnati, Boise State and Oregon in the mix?
Would someone please explain to me why we do not have a playoff, and come on, convince me. No lame, it can not be done because of time away from their studies. No lame, a playoff would take away from the regular season. Give me a break. This BCS system has made teams with two losses irrelevant as well as the bowl games. We all know that the only bowl game that matters is the BCS final game and this year in keeping with “tradition”, it will be played January 7th at 5pm. Is that really a Thursday night at the Rose Bowl? That is just great tradition. The only interest in the other bowl games will be alumni and fans of a particular school and the school getting paid to be in those bowl games.
Watch the games and see how many empty seats there are. How many empty seats would there be in a playoff system? Tell me how many of these bowl games will you leave work early to see: Meineke Car Care Bowl, Motor City Bowl, Insight Bowl, Brut Sun Bowl or the Gaylord Hotels Music City Bowl. You had better soup up your Tivo or DVR. I counted 34 bowl games and if I am off my a game or two, well forgive me. That means there are 68 teams playing in bowl games, over half of the 120 teams in FBS. When did the term FBS come into play? I hope the other schools that do not make it at least get nice participation ribbons.
The Heisman race looks to be a simple call as well. The top four candidates come down to Tim Tebow, Colt McCoy, Mark Ingram and a late push for Toby Gerhart. I think Ingram will finish fourth. He has had a great year 1,429 yards, 12 touchdowns and a 6.5 yards per carry and his team is undefeated. He is a great player but they will lose to Florida and he will lose his chance, plus he is only a sophomore. Something I learned this week is this storied program of the Bear, Joe Willie Namath and Kenny Stabler has never had a Heisman Trophy Winner. I was stunned!! Toby Gerhart of Stanford came on strong late, 1,736 yards rushing with 26 touchdowns and a 5.6 average. His team is 8-4 and they will not give it to a team ranked that low. So in my book it comes down to Tebow and McCoy. They have both had very good years but McCoy’s year is not as good as last years and Tebow’s is not as good as his Heisman winning season two years ago. It is a toss up.
I said at the beginning of the year that I was for McCoy and I will stand by that. His touchdowns to interceptions is 27-9, 3,328 yards passing and he has a 71.8 percentage completion. He ran for two touchdowns and 368 yards on the ground. Tebow has 17 touchdown throws with 4 picks and a 66.4% completion rate. He has thrown for 2166 yards, rushed for 796 yards and 13 touchdowns. That is a great year for anyone but Tebow. His sophomore year he was ridiculous. He threw for 32 touchdowns with only 6 interceptions and he ran for 895 yards and 23 touchdowns. Remember these two players should not have to be judged by their previous seasons. They are competing only against other players and only for this season. You can not go wrong with either one but I think McCoy wins a close one.
I said at the start of the season that I love college football and only a playoff would improve the game. The athletes are great, there are great fans all over the country and there are many amazing coaches at so many schools. If we could just get the big mucky mucks and this is a nice term for them, to see how great a playoff system would be. Other college sports have playoffs and so do other divisions in football. Pigheadedness, power and money are the only things stopping it from reality.
Locally congrats to Marshall Sperbeck at Sacramento State as the Hornets finished 5-6 and beat rival UC Davis for the second straight year. Sperbeck has the program headed in the right direction as he is getting more local recruits to stay home. The UC Davis game at Sac State was the third largest home attendance mark. The fans here are starved for a winner and I believe he will provide that soon. Kudos to Dannie Walker the head coach at Sacramento City College who in his first season as the head coach guided his team to a 6-5 season and a bowl victory. Coach Walker and his staff have a solid foundation on which to build for next season and also down the road. Finally, speaking of coaches, my next entry will be about two old guys that have taken heat and deserve better. So be ready to tell me why Paterno and Bowden must go.
